• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

SALT.

Search Toggle
  • What is Salt?
  • Principles
  • Seascape Map
  • Story Hub
  • Supply Chain
  • Dive Deeper
  • Search Toggle
  • SALT Feature

Paving over the Global Gender Gap in Fisheries- Dispatch from the Philippines

April 24, 2020
ladies on the floor of the fish processing warehouse

Bringing women into the fold

The Philippines

 

Mildred Mercene-Buazon doesn’t mince words when clarifying that gender equity is not about just counting the numbers of women and men present in a room. One first needs to start with appreciating the minority sex. “Appreciation is the biggest gap in gender work,” says Mercene-Buazon. The roles and contributions of women in fisheries were not fully appreciated, she says, particularly by policymakers. Though they contribute significantly in activities beyond harvesting, “they are being counted always in the hemline.”

panel showing three women
Ms. Jariya Sornkliang of SEAFDEC, Ms. Mildred Mercene-Buazon of BFAR, Ms. Movima Gono of General Santos LGU speaking at USAID Oceans event close-out. Photo by SALT

As the Chief Administrative Officer and Vice-Chair of the Gender Focal Point System for the Philippines Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources (BFAR) Central Office, Mercene-Buazon channels further inspiration from another gender specialist: Arlene “Jigsz” Nietes Satapornvanit. They both worked on the USAID Oceans and Fisheries Partnership, an initiative combatting illegal fishing in Southeast Asia that also supported an electronic traceability system for the Filipino tuna fishery. They worked to address human welfare and gender for the program. One simple method to foster gender awareness? Feature a woman in their supply chain graphics, says Jigsz (which they did).

SALT visited the Philippines in January and February 2020 to gain detailed insight and interview those working on the Philippines’ traceability endeavor with USAID Oceans. While browsing banners in a Manila hotel event room celebrating the program’s close, it appeared women were the majority in Southeast Asia’s fisheries. Upon closer inspection, it was actually a showcase of gender champions who supported equity and empowerment for women in the seafood industry, because female contributions in fisheries have been largely ignored.

women standing next to each other making the equals sign
Rebecca Andong (2nd from right) stands with female colleagues taking part in training users in innovative data solutions held on February 27-28, 2020. Photo courtesy of Rebecca Andong

With fishing roles in many cultures traditionally reserved for males, more recent concentration on gender equality shows where and how we’ve overlooked women in this field (more stories below). After all, women, too, depend on marine resources for survival, feeding their family, and account for nearly half the fisheries workforce. Without sex-disaggregated data though, it’s challenging to address gender in programs. The often-cited resource from 2012 on women’s contribution to fisheries showing that women are 50% of the workforce illustrates the dearth of gender-specific data.  Sex-disaggregated data is missing from more recent reports like FAO’s 2018 State of Fisheries and Aquaculture report, which compiles data from many countries. Not only is the data not collected uniformly through a gender lens, but those numbers also exclude other sectors, like processing or marketing. “How do you measure the impact of women in fisheries if there is no data?” asks Jigsz.

 

“
“How do you measure the impact of women in fisheries if there is no data?”
Arlene “Jigsz” Nietes Satapornvanit

Show me the data

Dr. Sumagaysay at the podium
Dr. Sumagaysay lays out what she and others on the USAID Oceans project learned about gender during the program’s close. Photo by SALT

Thus, USAID Oceans began with a gender analysis in General Santos, the tuna capital of the Philippines, assisted by the National Network on Women in Fisheries in the Philippines, Inc. (WINFISH) with Dr. Marieta Sumagaysay as Project Leader. Carrying out the analysis itself imparted awareness, says Sumagaysay, even with the data collectors themselves who came from Mindanao State University but were not in a gender field. It also helped differentiate where women and men differed in their needs by asking each gender what they perceived other genders needed. Other issues also emerged from the gender analysis. WINFISH, through a grant from USAID Oceans, implemented gender interventions to address them.

One interesting finding was that more males than females thought women had not been encouraged to join fishing trips. That could be attributed to less support from friends and family based on beliefs about women’s household role, or the purported level of stamina required for fishing. Furthermore, persistent cultural beliefs that women can cast bad luck on fishing might keep them from boarding boats. However, very few women actually expressed a desire to go to sea. Recommendations broke out what could be done practically to meet women’s needs (e.g. designated nursing areas), versus strategies to break up cultural norms (e.g. designing women-friendly boat facilities, give forklift driving lessons) (column below).

At the time of SALT’s visit, they had not yet put many findings to the task. Sumagaysay points out a need to boost the capacity for people to monitor gender programs. Awareness was one thing, but without oversight, how does an organization know it checked the boxes? It’s not enough to be sensitive to gender needs; it’s about responding to those needs.

As the analysis notes, the Philippines has consistently been the only Asian country with such a low gender gap in fisheries. In fact, the Philippines government mandates that five percent of its annual budget for each agency be allocated to programs for gender development. Those plans are subject to auditing and must be endorsed by the Philippine Commission on Women. One doesn’t have to wonder how to start weaving gender into programs; guidelines exist!

Recommendations from 2017 Gender Analysis for the Philippines

 

Addressing women’s practical gender needs concerns that will keep her healthy, and the provision of gender-sensitive facilities and amenities in the workplace, especially for mothers who combine worktime with reproductive roles of watching kids and nursing babies:

• Provision of protective gears

• IEC for reproductive health

• Improved ventilation of canneries

• Hazard pay for risky jobs

• Nursing area(s) at the workplace

• High chairs for production workers, to avoid long hours of standing

• Membership in the SSS, PhilHealth

• Provision of hauling equipment fit that considers the differences between men and women’s physical make-up.

 

 

Addressing women’s strategic gender needs pertains to her status as appendage to men’s work and/or her workspace being limited by beliefs, perceptions, practices, and social and traditional norms in the male-dominated tuna fishing sector:

• Designing woman-friendly boat facilities so they can fish, too

• Driving lessons for women, to enable them to use equipment like forklifts and cranes

• Provision of machineries/equipment that may allow women to do fish hauling

• Increased access to IT

• Leadership positions for women

• Organization of women’s groups

 

Reeling in fisheries

Gender and Development checklists help BFAR assess whether it adequately incorporated genderscreenshot of gender checklist into its fisheries programs. BFAR already stood out within the Department of Agriculture as leading on gender sensitivity, said Mercene-Buazon, but the analysis really encouraged those determining fisheries policy to jump on board. The USAID intervention also ratcheted awareness up for policy makers by spelling out specific activities, and showing they could bring gender into their electronic traceability pilot, says Rebecca Andong, Country Coordinator for USAID Oceans. In addition, the project developed a gender training handbook in collaboration with other experts for sustainable fisheries management. Based on research in the Philippines and Indonesia, USAID Oceans also put together a list of data to collect in fisheries that relate to human welfare and gender (pg 10-11).

 

List of data to collect on human welfare

While WINFISH’s Sumagaysay points out not all the groups working with BFAR had reached the same level of awareness, she gave a breakdown on how gender could be woven into electronic traceability work that goes beyond the Philippines:

  • Involve more women from the beginning, even during monitoring and recording the data. It’s not about inviting equal numbers of men & women; make sure they’re all equally engaged. Ensure the facilitator holding any workshops is sensitive to gender needs.
  • Conduct a gender analysis. Look at the difference between men’s and women’s situations in supply chains (e.g., roles, responsibilities, opportunities, access to resources). Use different analysis techniques to ensure issues are not perceived by one gender, but that they are actual issues.
  • Define gender-sensitive indicators.
  • Allocate a portion of the budget to gender research. Even if a budget exists, develop training on how to carry out gender research. Include gender in the organization’s goals when possible (e.g. “empowering both men and women”).
  • Ensure that the recommended solutions to address gender don’t lead to another gender problem.

Casting wider

members of the USAID Oceans sitting with their collaborators
The USAID Oceans and Fisheries Partnership closing event in Manila in February 2020. Photo by SALT

What does it look like if a company has already woven gender equality into its policy? Well, it seems a gender expert might still be necessary because carrying ideas out and monitoring progress requires oversight. To sustain a gender movement within an organization and call it successful, Sumagaysay listed a few more essentials: people and time. Additionally, gender champions need to be on hand, and management especially needs to buy in. The gender staff role should be the sole role for that person. Finally, beyond strong collaborations, it is helpful if the company has the ability to influence national agencies.

In recalling Mercene-Buazon’s words that gender is not about numbers of men versus women, I hesitate highlighting that our trip to the Philippines involved interviewing 17 people, 9 of which were women. Furthermore, we only questioned women about gender issues. Thus, one of SALT’s lessons from the trip is that we may have gained more gender insight posing gender questions to the men. In essence, the knowledge and tips we gathered were illustrative of SALT’s raison d’être: learning from each other helps advance progress in a field.

So why share what one country has done? “We are inspired by sharing experiences and practices of neighboring countries,” says Mercene-Buazon.

SALT couldn’t agree more.

Thus, in the spirit of knowledge exchange, we ask our readers to share with us and others how they integrated gender into their projects. Particularly when gender disparities in seafood may grow during the COVID-19 pandemic, swapping lessons is more important than ever.

group photo of SALT with BFAR and USAID Oceans staff
SALT’s Amy West, Brynn O’Donnell and BFAR’s Mildred Mercene-Buazon and Zaldy Perez, and USAID Oceans Rebecca Andong

The Hidden Half, Part I – Women’s role in Southeast Asia’s fisheries

This video provides an overview of women’s role in the fishing industry in Southeast Asia. Learn more in Part II – "Gender research in Southeast Asia’s fisheries.” While the video features communities and workplaces in Southern Mindanao, Philippines, it represents many of the gender roles and challenges women experience throughout the region and research tools and techniques that can apply throughout the region. Also available in Tagalog, Bahasa, Thai, and Vietnamese subtitles. Courtesy of USAID Oceans and Fisheries Partnership

The Hidden Half, Part II – Gender research in Southeast Asia’s fisheries

This video provides an introduction to conducting gender-specific research in Southeast Asia’s fisheries. While the video features communities and workplaces in Southern Mindanao, Philippines, it represents many of the gender roles and challenges women experience throughout the region and research tools and techniques that can apply throughout the region.  Also available in Bahasa, Tagalog, Thai, and Vietnamese subtitles. Courtesy of USAID Oceans and Fisheries Partnership

Gender Stories

The Other Half: Meet the Women Connecting Southeast Asia’s Seafood Supply Chain

USAID
Learn More

Women in fisheries management in Indonesia

Blue Ventures
Learn More

Women and the ocean: Changemakers challenge

World Ocean Initiative
Learn More

Gender Guides

  • Guidance Document

Gender Research in Fisheries and Aquaculture: A Training Handbook

USAID Oceans and Fisheries Partnership (USAID Oceans)
2018
This training guide was developed to build the capacity of practitioners, experts, and students working in fisheries and aquaculture in gender theory and practice through interactive presentations and case studies.Press enter to go to this resource, Gender Research in Fisheries and Aquaculture: A Training Handbook
  • Guidance Document

Gender and Development Checklist for the Fisheries Sector

Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources
This set of gender and development (GAD) checklists was developed to ensure the programs and projects of the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources (BFAR) are addressing key gender issues or concerns. The checklists cover livelihood and food security, fisheries and coastal resource management and conservation, research, and training.Press enter to go to this resource, Gender and Development Checklist for the Fisheries Sector
  • Community Feature

Designing gender-responsive technology for more equitable supply chains

USAID Oceans and Fisheries Partnership (USAID Oceans)
2019
In the Asia-Pacific region, women constitute half of the fisheries workforce; yet, women's vital roles and needs have traditionally been overlooked. This feature highlights the findings of the USAID Oceans and Fisheries Partnership around the limitations women face in the fisheries workforce.Press enter to go to this resource, Designing gender-responsive technology for more equitable supply chains
  • Guidance Document

Advancing Gender in The Environment: Gender in Fisheries—A Sea of Opportunities

USAID & IUCN
2019
This guide summarizes research on the intersection of gender and wild-caught fisheries, exploring the ways in which fisheries offer important entry points to enhance gender equality and women’s economic empowerment while also contributing to more effective interventions and more sustainable outcomes.Press enter to go to this resource, Advancing Gender in The Environment: Gender in Fisheries—A Sea of Opportunities
  • Guidance Document

Pacific Handbook for Gender Equity and Social Inclusion in Coastal Fisheries and Aquaculture

Pacific Community
2019
This handbook is designed to give practical guidance on improving gender and social inclusion in coastal fisheries and aquaculture for staff working in fisheries agencies in Pacific Island countries and territories.Press enter to go to this resource, Pacific Handbook for Gender Equity and Social Inclusion in Coastal Fisheries and Aquaculture
  • Report

The role of women in the seafood industry

FAO & GLOBEFISH
2015
The primary aim of this report is to increase awareness of business leaders and policy makers, to expand their knowledge and sensitization about the value women bring to the seafood industry, and to encourage them to consider each time they develop a new project or a policy: “Have we not overlooked women?”Press enter to go to this resource, The role of women in the seafood industry

Written by

SALT staff Amy West
Amy West, M.Sc.
SALT Project Director
Tags: FAO, WorldBank, Oceans, USAID, Disaggregated Data, Gender, BFAR, Females, Covid-19, Philippines, Fisheries, WSI,
Share:

More Stories

Taking Stock cover page
  • Community Feature

FROM FiTI: TAKING STOCK – Online Transparency of Fisheries Management Information

May 25, 2022
photo: AFO staff members
  • Community Feature

Q&A with Aqua-Farms Organization: Applying the Comprehensive Traceability Principles in Tanzania

May 16, 2022
photo of small boats
  • SALT Feature

Promoviendo el Espíritu de Colaboración en América Latina y el Caribe Través de los Principios de Trazabilidad de los Productos del Mar

April 20, 2022
photo of small boats
  • SALT Feature

Bringing Seafood Traceability Principles and the Spirit of Collaboration to Latin American and the Caribbean

April 20, 2022
Octopus fisheries in Tanzania
  • Community Feature
  • SALT Feature

Collaborative Traceability Project Brings Triple Impact to Tanzanian Fisheries

March 21, 2022
Header for SEAFOOD source article
  • Community Feature

From Seafood Source: Better data in the time of COVID-19: Opportunities for advancing eCDT in wild-capture fisheries

February 24, 2022
  • Community Feature
  • SALT Feature

SALT Grantee Final Update: Consultation Workshop on the National Roadmap and Guidelines for e-logbook and eCDT in Vietnam

February 10, 2022
What's next in 2022 title
  • SALT Feature

SALT’s Successes in 2021 and What’s Next in 2022

February 8, 2022
Vericatch title page
  • Community Feature

From Vericatch: Why Is Traceability Important For The Seafood Supply Chain – Q&A With Julian Hawkins

January 18, 2022
RECEIVE UPDATES FROM SALT SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

Footer Logo
  • What is Salt?
  • Principles
  • Seascape Map
  • Story Hub
  • Supply Chain
  • Dive Deeper
  • Linkedin
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy

© 2022 SALT

This product is made possible by the generous support of the American people through the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). The contents are the responsibility of FishWise and do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the United States Government.